Randy Couture vs James Toney would this end the whats better Boxing or MMA question?

No, it solves nothing. You can't compare the two because whoever has home turf would win. It's like saying who would win in a fight a bear or a shark? In water the shark will win, and on land the bear would win. I will say that Toney at least has a chance to knock Couture out, whereas if they were in a boxing ring Couture would have NO chance whatsoever. The two sports are apples and oranges, it's a matter of opinion which one you like more and if you like one more than the other then that is fine, but it doesn't mean the one you like less sucks. I like and watch both sports, if I had to choose one to watch the rest of my life it would be Boxing, but that is just my opinion.